Coating and Paint Analysis

Anderson Materials Evaluation has a long history of characterizing coatings and painted surfaces and solving problems in such materials and at the interfaces to which they are applied. We have characterized or investigated problems with electronics coatings, protective coatings for aerospace and defense, coatings to promote adhesive bonding, coatings to prevent corrosion, multilayered optical reflective and anti-reflective coatings, thermal protection coatings, automotive and construction coatings, high lubricity coatings, hard coatings, abrasion-resistant coatings, hydrophobic and hydrophilic coatings, low VOC coatings, radar absorption coatings, chemical release coatings, and sensor coatings.

We have dealt with many issues of surface contamination or ill-preparation of substrate materials.  We have contended with many deposition problems and different growth characteristics.  Curing problems, thickness measurements, volatile organic content measurements, residual stress, delamination and peeling, chemical attack, thermal and radiation degradation, agglomeration of filler particles, voids and fisheyes, diffusion between multiple layers, unusual wear, stains, and changes of color and texture have all been subjects of our many investigations.

Metallographic Optical Microscopy / SEM Analysis:

  • Cross-section analysis to determine the thickness of the coating, voids, and pores
  • Radial sectioner analysis to measure coating thickness, as an alternative to standard cross section analysis
  • Determine grain size, structure, and multiple chemical domains in polycrystalline metal and inorganic films
  • Check thickness and fill particle uniformity of paint or thickness and chemistry of metal films
  • Check fill particle distribution and detect particle agglomeration in paint
  • Topography and film crack morphology
  • Detect coating holidays and fisheyes
  • Observe agglomeration of UV protecting and color-providing inorganic particles
  • Detect presence, prevalence, and size of nibs
  • Determine degree of cure of paint by examining the sidewall of MEK double-rub tested painted surfaces

Fig. 1. This image showed the clearcoat over a base coat of white paint had been breached by a 100 rub MEK solvent double-rub test, which indicated insufficient cure of the clearcoat coating.  This image is of an area of the sidewall created by they double-rub test.  The topcoat clearcoat layer is shown at the top and appears white in this image due to the high reflectivity of the silica gel particles in that coating layer.  The basecoat white paint containing both titanium dioxide and silica particles is shown at the bottom with a layer of the basecoat free of titanium dioxide particles due to their having settled.  Both SEM/EDX and XPS analyses helped to confirm this interpretation of the results, though smearing of titanium dioxide particles made the interpretation of their results less than straightforward.  The metallographic microscope proved most useful in this investigation.

Fig. 2.  Nomarski phase interference contrast microscopy was used to find areas of an anti-reflective coating of many layers damaged by chemical cleaning of high value lens elements.  The outermost protective layer of the coating structure was breached by the chemical, which then reacted with the underlying layers.  The darkest areas at the bottom of the image are the least damaged areas.

FTIR or Infrared Spectroscopy Analysis:

  • Identify the organic coating
  • Detect carbonates, phosphates, sulfates, nitrates, and nitrites
  • With specular reflectance accessory, determine the chemistry as a function of depth and separate signal from multiple layers
  • Determine whether coating absorbs water with relative comparisons
  • Check coatings for degradation due to aging, UV exposure, thermal history, or other radiation exposure

XPS or ESCA Surface Analysis:

  • Determine chemical composition of coating binders or matrix polymers
  • Determine the actual composition of films and coatings deposited by PVD, ALD, CVD, electrochemically deposited, electroless deposition, and other films or coatings whose chemistry is process dependent
  • Detect contaminants on surfaces to be coated
  • Determine cause of coating peeling or delamination
  • Determine the composition of filler particles or flakes, often in conjunction with TGA analysis
  • Determine the composition of underlying anodized metal layers with or without sealant layers
  • Determine the composition of corrosion prevention undercoatings and primers
  • Identify composition of particles causing nibs
  • Determine the composition with depth of multi-layered thin film coatings such as anti-reflective coatings, reflective coatings, and masking coatings, see this example of the analysis of a reflective coating.
  • Determine the composition of coatings on the surfaces of fibers.  Report on the analysis of coatings on polyethylene fibers and the fiber surfaces after stripping off the coatings.

Fig. 3.  The black spots on this gold-coated electrical contact pin were examined with XPS and found to be due to nickel oxide, NiO.  When gold is electroplated over nickel film base layers on copper and the gold is very full of impurities, many easy diffusion pathways exist for the nickel to segregate to the surface under a chemical gradient to bond with oxygen.  Note the multi-color appearance of the gold and its very granular appearance.  This is indicative of low quality gold electroplate.

Fig. 4.  The sand shown in the microscopic image is coated in order to produce grout of varying colors.  XPS analysis of the coating composition and its degree of coverage was part of an intellectual property theft investigation.  The results helped our client win the largest award of damages in an intellectual theft case to that time in Connecticut.

Thermogravimetric Analysis or TGA:

  • Determine oxidation behavior
  • Determine weight % of filler minerals and identify filler material with XPS analysis
  • Measure weight of absorbed/adsorbed water
  • Determine weight of solvents and volatiles in liquid paint for VOC emission testing
  • Measure weight loss upon heating to measure weight of multiple organic components and susceptibility to oxidative decomposition

Differential Scanning Calorimetry or DSC:

  • Determine crystalline phase changes
  • Measure melting temperatures
  • Measure heat of fusion
  • Determine cure temperature
  • Measure glass transition temperature
  • Measure degree of cure

Thermomechanical Analysis or TMA:

  • Measure coefficient of thermal expansion
  • Measure softening temperature
  • Determine degree of crystallinity
  • Measure glass transition temperature
  • Measure shrinkage due to volatization of organic solvents or water

SEM / EDX Analysis:

  • Examine surfaces for cracks, voids, or loose particles due to degradation
  • Examine additive particles for proper size and evidence of excessive clumping or agglomeration
  • Examine cross sections for thickness measurements
  • EDX is useful for detecting the interface between paint and primer in many cases
  • EDX may be useful in detecting the interface between a clearcoat and a paint layer

Electrochemistry:

  • Corrosion resistance due to a protective coating on metal in various electrolytes
  • Detection of coating holidays
  • Time to corrosion failure due to water penetration and absorption
  • EIS measurement of resistance and capacitance changes in coatings
  • Corrosion rate measurements
  • Undercoat corrosion
  • Measure activity in holidays or pores through coatings

Contact Angle Measurement:

  • Determine the surface tension or energy of the substrate before applying the coating
  • Determine the surface tension of energy of the coated surface

Profilometry:

  • Measure the surface roughness of the coating

Viscometry:

  • Measure the viscosity of liquid paint or particle emulsions
  • Measure resin demand for particle emulsions
  • Measure the effect of pH on viscosity